Skip to main content

Use Teachers Wisdom And Not AI For Grading Students



An interesting question was posed on twitter yesterday “Is teacher vs. algorithm the next culture war?”. Of course, this was a reaction to the enormous stooshie that is happening with the awarding of exam grades. In Scotland, the outrage was so much that the Government had to step in or step back depending on how you want to spin it and junk AI results and go back to the teacher recommendations.


I am not about to wade into the arguments about the pro and cons of using AI-algorithms to decide outcomes. This twitter thread will give a good overview of the grading scandal. Our whole world is now dominated by a computer using algorithms to remember that particular pale ale you like to drink on Friday night while listening to obscure French stoner rock bands from the late 1960s. For the most part, the addition of having AI in our lives has been a welcome one, for me, mostly discovering bands on YouTube. I have, however, yet to succumb to the temptation of using any of the digital assistants. I am aware that my data is being harvested, stored in some vast database by some Evil Tech Media Gaint no matter how much I try to avoid it. I can at least limit their harvesting to clicking things on the Internet and the fact that I was in the pub on Friday. Also, I enjoy arguing with my wife about whether or not a certain actor was in that rubbish TV show, without some digital voice telling me I am very much mistaken.


I think, though, that we are relying too much on AI-algorithms for things that do require a more nuanced perspective. There was a quote I remember from Msc Multimedia course days about being able to teach intelligence but not wisdom. Intelligent people can design and programme what looks like brilliant AI. It is never going to be wise, though. Programming wisdom is a whole level of complexity that is still in the realms of sci-fi fantasy.


The upside to the algorithm grading scandal was it revealed the uncomfortable biases in our education system. Pooer areas with large classes had more of their grades reduced. In contrast, private schools were mostly unaffected. I would like to think that this was not a deliberate ploy, more an oversight in its application. Twitter is a swirl of conspiracies, some are entirely plausible, and then you have to remember its Twitter.


I know nothing about today’s schools. My only reference point to this was my experience when I was at school in the 1980s. I failed every exam bar one. I had a terrible attitude at school and paid the price. Most of my teachers went out on a limb with me and let me progress on my chosen courses. I remember going to the teachers I got on with and begging to get on their courses. I am not sure how they managed to swing the appeals. However, they did, and I am forever grateful. If I had been reliant on some algorithm, I would have been a goner that is for sure.


My suggestion is that we should always let teachers be the primary arbitrators on grading. Let’s leave the AI to figuring out our favourite IPA’s and random stoner rock band.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Feedback.

Yes, indeed I am still very much unemployed. I have had a couple of video interviews that have sadly been unsuccessful. One of the interviews I did was with someone I used to work with so there was no hiding place in that one. There were two pieces of telling feedback from them. The first was that they thought that maybe the learning curve in the job might be too much for me. They thought I was too "Product based" and they were "Project-based" which I absolutely understand but I think I could easily transition to that kind of work process but they obviously  did not feel that. I should cotton on to that in the interview but did not at the time. The second piece of feedback was actually quite interesting and did make me sit up to think. They thought I was too negative about my previous employer and my experience there; which as I have already documented was not exactly a happy one. This has got me thinking about how do you go about talking about previous employment e...
Post a Comment
Read more

Day 19 of 2022: Feeling a Bit Useless

Imposter Syndrome kicking in It might be mid-week blues or me having an off day, but today I felt like I was not good enough for my job. The old confidence took a but of dunt when I lost my job a couple of years back. I am not sure I have worked that through the how's and whys of what happened. That might be for another day, I am kicking that particular can down the road. Today I felt as if was not contributing enough, I am trying to feel my around and a complicated Software Package. It is a bit like being in a dark room. I am also blindfolded and there is a voice yelling "Why haven't you found it yet-get a move on". One crumb of comfort is that I am in this situation with other people who are in the same predicament. We keep bumping into each other and saying "Have you found the door yet", "Nope" and off we bumble. When I lost the job, I did contemplate "I am cut out to be Tester?" Today I found myself contemplating that question again....
Post a Comment
Read more

Day 25 of 2022 : Behind the Walled Garden of Delights

In Your Garden of Delights.. The other day I noticed a story about Disney clawing back a lot of their content is on Netflix. It would appear the days of shared content across platforms is diminishing. The streaming providers want to keep you in their walled garden for as much as possible. If you are a serious tv watcher you are now going to have to subscribe to at least three if not four providers. All that to watch your fave film or TV show. My arithmetic is not that great but it would be safe to say that would be not shy of well over £350 a year. Ouch. We have Prime and Netflix and we do watch them a lot. I had Prime when it was Love Film and £4.99 was a good price. When Amazon came along and waved their wonga at Love Film I continued to only pay £4.99 for years and years. It was down the contract that Amazon had to fulfil. I have since upgraded to a Prime user so now fork out £7.99. My wife decided to pay for Netflix, as she wanted to watch a certain show for a bit. I have to be hon...
Post a Comment
Read more